I have just spent a year in 16 countries in West Africa.
On the whole, people here are extremely happy / content / friendly.
In all honesty, they make Canadians look unfriendly and unhappy.
I know you strongly believe everything we have invented in the modern world makes us happier (almost everyone does) You really, really, REALLY need to see with you own eyes, not just listen to what you have been told.
Pretty much any time things aren't just horrible and desperate, people are more than capable of being happy. People are very adaptable in that regard.
The other thing we tend to do as human beings is tell ourselves that people who are better off can't be (that much) happier. Or people who are better off convincing themselves that because their lives aren't perfect that all circumstances are essentially the same as far as happiness goes and that people with less or who are living closer to the edge are actually happier than they are.
There's a wide range of circumstances people can live with and still find happiness. Very few of us have a hard requirement of being on the very top rung of the ladder to be happy. And there's no particular rung on the ladder where happiness becomes possible.
It also raises our threshold for happiness in the long term, and we spend more and more of our time working to sustain that. It's kind of like a never ending drug addiction. I'm not surprised to hear people living simpler lives appear happier.
Hundreds of millions of people live with a lot less technology and stuff that you, are extremely happy, and are not hunter-gatherers.
On the other hand, the Symbicort I inhale daily to avoid COPD (and the emergency room treatments I received when I was younger) are pretty high tech.
My eyesight is very crappy and I have spent some asthma related evenings in the emergency room. Assuming I survived infancy, I would not have survived to adulthood and I wouldn't have enjoyed the process.
IMHO, however, people who talk about how happy people are in subsistence and developing societies haven't actually spent much time in them.
Happiness does not change much as long you can meet the basic needs for food / water / safety. So, the general assumption that people are about as happy works across a huge range of lifestyles.
On the other hand primitive lifestyles have significantly shorter lifespans which is objectively an issue.
The most shocking difference from expectations is happiness tends toward a steady state even after major life changes such as winning the lottery. People in prison for example are often happier than you might assume as long as their personal safety is not at issue and they can socialize.
Happiness is subjective, not objective.
>Happiness does not change much as long you can meet the basic needs for food / water / safety.
See Maslow's Hierarchy.
>On the other hand primitive lifestyles have significantly shorter lifespans which is objectively an issue.
What do you mean "objectively an issue"? One does not need to live a long life to live a fullfilling life. Many of these tribal socities have survived far longer than other civilized societies because they live in equilibrium with their environment.
There are no objective biological tests for depression (or happiness), the psychiatric diagnosis relies exclusively on subjective observations (i.e. asking the person about their feelings).
>"psychiatric diagnosis still relies exclusively on fallible subjective judgments rather than objective biological tests."
-Allen Frances
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allen_Frances
The idea of happiness as a purely material objective phenomenon has been complicit in the exploitation and destruction of the Amazon and its inhabitants over the past centuries.
Depression is considered when people have a null result on those tests, therefore there are physical tests for depression. Just not in the way testing is normally thought of.
measure your own well-being by spending a week programming vs spending a week in a hut in a forest.
I would, in no way whatsoever, be interested in such a procedure and I think it's safe to say that applies to the vast majority. Thus, it must be presumed that the happiness of an individual or a group is not really a measurement of their 'fulfillment' even if it sounds like a reasonable premise in a vacuum.