Interesting, completely different from my teaching and CTO experience. Also interesting it looks very different from German universities, where e.g. in Berlin the majority of students I've interviewed can't do FizzBuzz in an online interview.
How would you assess "good programmer"?
From a very practical point of view, mine would be something like can write a feature on his/her own, gets transactions correct, doesn't create performance bugs that show in live systems, good maintainable, readable, understandable architecture. We definetly could not get everybody on that level even with a lot of mentoring.
We had a CTO meetup recently and mostly everyone shared the same experience.
Coming back, would be interested in "How would you assess good programmer"?