Take a look at what the car replaced. Horses were and are wildly dangerous.
That doesn't say anything about which is worse: horses or cars. I wonder if any study has been done about that. It'd have to be complex, e.g. covering sicknesses from manure, sicknesses from leaded gasoline, sicknesses from pollution &c.
There's no chance that humans would go back to carriages as a realistic transport method. Shouldn't we be comparing against electric bicycles and public transport networks?
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/bike-blog/2011/aug/1...