China has a huge and possibly insurmountable lead in not just existing built hardware, but a head start in the know-how of rolling out new ASIC designs to production, (relatively) cheap factories to mass-produce hardware, access to cheap/state-subsidized electricity, and (in this hypothetical scenario of nationalization) the support of the central government of one of the largest/most-powerful nations on Earth.
Chinese miners currently control significantly more than 50% of Bitcoin mining.
If the government takes control of the the miners, they take control of the bitcoin network. There's plenty of mischief they could make with that if they were so inclined.
Having 51% of hash power doesn't mean you mine 100% of blocks. That's not how Bitcoin works. With 51% you will probably mine around 51%.
This, of course, is assuming that the 51% doesn't create blocks considered invalid on the other chain. This would cause a hard fork and it's exactly what is happening now with Bitcoin Cash, except with a much smaller fraction than 51%.
So no, what you are describing cannot happen with the default rules.
They are building on some of their blocks and some of the other miner's blocks. This doesn't make them faster.
Whenever a 49%er mines a block, there is a temporary fork. The 49% and the 51% start mining on two completely separate branches, both of which progress at half speed. Eventually the 51% branch is longer, and the 49% discard their previous work and switch to it. So the 49% were using their blocks, and now they are using the 51% blocks, but never both at the same time.
The canonical blockchain does not progress at full speed. Half the blocks that get mined eventually become orphans.
It would be impossible for the 49% to build on everyone's blocks, because the 51%-created blocks are always mutually incompatible preexisting 49%-created blocks.
> This, of course, is assuming that the 51% doesn't create blocks considered invalid on the other chain.
Yes, of course.
There are really two separate scenarios we're talking about here. Miner activated hard forks, which are a real thing that have happened (though not exactly like you describe), and a hypothetical situation where a group of miners agree to create an exclusive chain that is also backwards compatible. I'm no expert but I don't think that would have the intended result.
That's the difference between a hard fork and a 51% attack. In a 51% attack you keep making normal bitcoin blocks, just the ones you want.
Think back to what I said about crossword puzzles. If China had a world-class crossword puzzle team, winning every competition, why on earth would they seize their own team's pencils? It wouldn't stop the competitions from happening, and it wouldn't stop other teams from winning them.
I'm not trying to be a pedantic prick on the internet, so please excuse me if I'm coming off that way, but I enjoy this topic a lot, probably too much.