We've moved our open source bits to the eclipse foundation recently..and surprise! We're still the primary developers. Granted, this was recently, but apache projects can also go to the apache attic where they go to "retire".
Generally, you still need some sort of revenue stream in there to sustain/subsidize a "community".
A lot of apache projects have a company behind them driving development.
That's kind of the point though - a quick survey at download time, or a post on a blog describing proposed pricing and the caddy-sponsors header would have given them a lot of the information they needed to make an informed choice. Instead they made assumptions and got it very wrong.
Unlike most commercial launches, they already had a large userbase to gather information from, they just chose not to use it.
Those blog posts that 95%+ of customers never read or, if they do, won't bother commenting on?
Good luck.
They've already got something built into the download page to configure plugins. All it would have taken was an additional question and a few radio options:
I plan on using Caddy for:
[ ] my personal website [ ] my startup [ ] other commercial
> Those blog posts that 95%+ of customers never read or, if they do, won't bother commenting on?People already follow their social accounts etc. to be notified of updates. Plenty of people will read a post "We're thinking of charging for Caddy", and even a 5% response rate would be in the hundreds or thousands.
Plenty of people have done it in much more difficult markets with fewer resources. It's never easy, but Caddy had some good options they never used.
Welcome to the world of market research. It's how you avoid launching a bad product at the wrong price. The alternative is getting it very publicly wrong and having to backtrack.