You can use ansible.verbose="vvvv" if you're calling the play via vagrant's ansilbe provisioner.
In that case, running ansible verbosely gave enough info to point me in the direction of fixing what was wrong with my ssh setup (can't remember now what it was).
I think the biggest advantage (in your case), is Ansible's idempotent nature. It takes way more work to make your shell script idempotent that it does writing a playbook for the same thing.
I'm also curious about your current dev environments. Do you call Ansible through Vagrant or are you using completely Ansible to spin everything up? Getting the runtime environment installed/configured correctly can sometimes be a challenge for people just starting out (it was challenging for me at least) and if you have 10s/100s of engineers trying to set up Ansible properly and run playbooks themselves, you may have a bad time.