This in turns means that these other people don't increase their ratios and end up in the same situation. You have an artificial 0-sum game for absolutely no good reason. Then you need freeleech periods or bonuses to make up for the ratio credit "deflation".
I think it would make more sense to punish people who never seed (seeding if nobody is downloading is fine, you can't do anything about it) and incite people to seed torrents with a low seed count.