Shouldn't it be the inverse? Why the need for another device, if you're already carrying the smartphone?
Shouldn't it be the inverse? Why the need for another device, if you're already carrying the smartphone?
My Sansa Clip years ago was a far better device for music and survived the washing machine a couple of times.
Like how is "the music player battery lasts for 5 days, and phone battery lasts 1.5 days" a pro-music-player argument: it means the options are "charge every day" and "charge every day, and additionally a second thing every 5 days", right?
My phones never last 1.5 days of use if they have to play music all the time as well, at least not once the battery is a year old. With my current one, having to balance usage to make sure it'll be available when I need it is getting annoying and includes "no music now".
At least in the past storage in phones was needlessly expensive and scarce, this has gotten better, and you can still get enough phones with microSD slots, despite the best attempts of some manufacturers to get rid of them.
Bluetooth also has gotten more reliable, that helps, but at least among the devices I've tried that's really a recent development, and still not perfect.
I totally get that other people will evaluate this differently (and/or buy better phones than me), but I don't see it as an obvious answer.
A modern phone compared to a Zune?
> I use a USB stick music player. It's essentially like a usb drive with a headphone jack.
This specific point clearly doesn't apply to a Zune, so we can assume remaining Zune users have other individual reasons why they like what they have.
It's not such a question for the parent though, as they said that: "I never use my smartphone for music, I don't see the need" -- which implies they ALSO have/carry a smartphone.
> Why the need to use the smartphone FOR MUSIC (and look into and accept the compromises coming with that) when you already own a device made perfectly for the task of playing music?