Ass-chewing isn't generally beneficial as it makes people defensive and potentially angry themselves. The mea culpa is good: "And again sorry, I screwed up, it should not have happened, my perspective was incorrect and I know I need to make it right." This is a great response, defuses the conversation and makes it clear that it's going to be fixed.
As someone who's gotten chewed out before, all it does is leave a bad taste in your mouth and most likely going to quit the company or possibly the project. Honestly, the threat of rejecting future commits and/or rejecting his opinions was by far the best thing in Linus' response, b/c those cut straight to your potential to contribute to the project.
That seems to be his direct intent, and being angry does help get this point across.
> the threat of rejecting future commits and/or rejecting his opinions was by far the best thing in Linus' response, b/c those cut straight to your potential to contribute to the project.
When online, people can't tell when you're being subtle.
Bluntly telling someone they really screwed up and need to stop denying it isn't bullying. Someone being mean isn't bullying.
Linus has been known to have some hostility to 'security developers' in the past, so I'm also going in with some skepticism. But I'm not seeing him be unreasonable here.
These are human processes, a lot of personality, dedication, and sacrifice is involved in these projects.
Especially when it's a personality style combined with the fact it comes from a place of caring deeply about the subject... then the motivation is not just trying to hurt the other person. This is the maturity, the point you learn to see in people.
Clearly Linus is heavily attached to the project and the person he replied to has been pushing an unpopular position for 3 weeks. It didn't come out of nowhere. He's also not new to this game. He's not some new intern, who doesn't know the deal, getting bullied by a CEO.
There has been a big culture trend to treat every small comment as potentially devastatingly hurtful, training kids to be thin skinned, and in my opinion, this highly disincentivizes honesty and will create a lot of inefficiency in business. As it requires a significant time investment to make sure even seemingly harmless statements are not 'hurtful', employing subtlety and skirting around an issue indirectly requires significant cognitive load. In a high volume, high pressure projects like the Linux mailing list this could really add up and generate bad decision making, as people will rather avoid an issue then invest in saying it carefully.
The ROI in that trend is questionable, as you can train people to see beyond the words and look at the person's real motivation and meaning, as it is not a given raw honesty is coming from a place of personal attack.
That said, obviously otherwise real hurtful and mean attacks, without an underlying purpose and genuine motivation other than to hurt the person, should never be tolerated. But sacrificing full honesty and non-heavily filtered emotional opinions in order to never have these personal attacks is just not worth it IMO.
Yes, by all means people should try to develop a thick skin and would benefit from that throughout life. That would lead to X% improvement and Y% who still were dealt with in a counterproductive way.
There's a wide range of capacity for dealing with this stuff. General Macarthur was infinitely strong minded, but when he saw someone with war induced PTSD in a hospital bed he slapped him across the face for being a coward. I give him the benefit of the doubt that his own strength made it difficult to see what was a much less understood thing back then. This case is not even close to PTSD, but the concept is the same in that emotional capacity varies widely, even when we practice resiliency.
Linus caring passionately about the project I think is irrelevant, the question is what leadership approach yields the desired results with the least downsides.
>...a culture trend to treat every small comment as potentially devastatingly hurtful, >training kids to be thin skinned...this highly disincentivizes honesty and will... >create a lot of inefficiency in business...
That's the fallacy right there. There's nothing stopping people from demanding excellence, demanding results. Indeed, high standards should be the bar, and if their are multiple ways apparent to achieve them, the one with the least negatives should be applied. That's smart for both business and morality.
>>sacrificing full honesty and non-heavily filtered emotional opinions in order >>to never have these personal attacks is just not worth it
This is another critical point. I do not advocate (and I think many others as well) for one second that honesty, directness, fidelity, and impact of communication be sacrificed. I think in some cases you do have to break eggs to make an omelette. I just believe the cases where being an asshole is required to achieve a certain level of effectiveness is in general exceptional, and that it also wasn't the only way in this particular case.
Btw, none of this is really a critique of Linus. Yes I think he could have done better, but there are thousands of conversations like this everyday. This just happens to be a mini case study in leadership styles and the options for achieving the required results.
I believe you mean General Patton here, not Macarthur. I know this story well and I don't think this came from a place of personal attack either. It came from a place of misunderstanding. This is the critical difference I'm getting at. The personal motivation is what matters, not the lack of preemptive filtering of the words or actions themselves.
The solution there was an evolution of the understanding of PTSD. The General was caring deeply about such an important thing, such as not letting well-trained soldier be a coward and hiding in the hospital when other men are dying in the field. And he saw many young kids die and it made him raw.
It's also been said the General may have had his own PTSD and emotional problems, and he wanted to attack the weaker man who made HIM feel that way.
Ultimately he was wrong factually, for misunderstanding the motivations of the soldier. The soldier wasn't being a coward (AFAIK) but suffering from serious mental trauma. If this happened in 2017 it would be a different story because Patton should have known better and what he did was abusive in that context. AND Patton could also have been better informed about his own risks of behavioral problems if he had modern science and education.
Does this mean Patton's brutal honesty was the problem? Or was it the general understanding of PTSD? I believe the latter.
Ultimately this doesn't mean Patton shouldn't have been brutally honest with his regular troops on the battlefield. Which he was, and he was also brutally effective at running the war too, and he was loved for it by his troops. The guy in the hospital is a different story and should have never happened, but I don't think I would have sacrificed Patton's honesty because society and common sense was wrong about a few subjects.
However the point was not Patton did wrong, as I mentioned I believe he just wasn’t aware.
The point was people have massively different reactions to emotional stress. This is why two people with identical wat experience may or may not get ptsd. Training for emotional stress has limits.
You keep saying you wouldn’t want to change the virtues of these leaders. I’m trying to say (forget Patton) most times their virtues don’t come inherently from being an asshole. Their virtues come many personality traits, strength, courage, talent. We don’t have to, and shouldn’t give up thes virtues. That doesn’t meant they can never be optimized.
> getting an incompetent bozo fired
> "bullying"
The interesting issue is more of leadership.
1) Is it possible to get equally direct and effective results in a different style?
2) Does Linus care about the answer to question (1), or would he act out of emotion even if he knew knew there was a equal or more productive way?
Assholism is not the solution to great leadership. It’s one of many techniques leaders use. Some leaders are effective using it frequently, but it’s important to note it’s usually not required because there are trade offs and downsides, both morally and amorally from a pure efficiency standpoint.
"Everybody"? Sanders also said a bunch of things like they are, and he said them politely. Especially factoring in grass roots support, he was more popular than Hillary and would have wiped the floor with Trump.
If you allow your media and "leaders" to sweep people like Sanders under the rug, you make people like Trump inevitable. And then you still don't learn. There can be worse things than Trump, so much infinitely worse; and they will come to pass if you insist on this trajectory.
> Especially factoring in grass roots support, he was more popular than Hillary
If that is objectively true, he should have won the primary. He didn't.
> and would have wiped the floor with Trump.
[CITATION NEEDED]
> If you allow > And then you still don't learn > if you insist
Why are you calling me out? I didn't vote for him. Go project somewhere else.
Unprovable counterfactual (and disputed by actual facts but ho hum.)
> you make people like Trump inevitable.
No, it was nothing to do with Sanders - it was Comey, gerrymandering, gutting the VRA, voter suppression, a complicit media, an electoral system that vastly overpowers the southern states, and astonishing institutionalised countrywide racism and sexism.
The people who don't have those tools control the horizontal, they control the vertical too. If they say your personality is wrong by definition, who are you to question them?
Without getting snarky, that's just the status quo right now. In some number of years they'll treat it like a big discovery that their previous assessment of all social interaction wasn't 100% perfect. Let's just hope that when it comes the pendulum swings our way and I get to stop wearing an emotionally-dishonest husk of a personality to the office.
[0] For the sake of avoiding predictable tangents, I mean aggression that is obviously not going to escalate to physical responses, or even anything more than rejecting patches.
But my dad was ex-military, then a logging contractor, then a heavy equipment mechanic, and I grew up working with him. When there are firearms, chainsaws, bulldozers, or heavy objects dangling from cranes, you don't have the luxury of couching your criticism in weasel-words or crafting the compliment-criticism sandwich. If somebody is fucking up, you let them know in no uncertain terms, because somebody could get hurt.
It is this that gave us things like smilies and Poe's Law.