So, an empty acre of land across the street from Central Park (I know, I know, but pretend it exists) is taxed the same, under an LVT, as that same acre sitting under a big mixed-use apartment/retail building. The building itself isn't taxed (though its presence will likely have a small effect on the overall rate in the area, provided it acts to increase the value of surrounding land).
Introduces confusion into a system that otherwise can't get too out of whack; after all, any arms-length sale of a property gets you a darn good idea of how much it is worth for taxation purposes. But since land is not usually sold separate from the buildings on it, an LVT allows perpetual divergence, and in the end you'll have ultra-valuable properties whose worth is, supposedly, all in the building and thus not taxed at all.
The point is to lower property taxes on the rich, raise them on the poor. LVT will have that effect, and that's the primary intent of most backers. In developed cities, the taxable property base will shift heavily from the city center toward the outskirts of the city.
Easy way to approach thinking about it: "large commercial buildings should be exempted from property tax, but as the city still needs funding, that lost revenue will be made up by raising everyone else's property taxes". It's a straight subsidy from the edges of the city to the center.
You can already attempt this with current property tax system. Somehow you never hear about people doing this one weird trick to avoid paying any property taxes. I guess it must be not so easy as you claim.
> Easy way to approach thinking about it: "large commercial buildings should be exempted from property tax, but as the city still needs funding, that lost revenue will be made up by raising everyone else's property taxes". It's a straight subsidy from the edges of the city to the center.
If that large commercial building is in the city center, then the land underneath it is valuable, and therefore owner will pay large tax bill just the same. And if you are concerned that in LVT system, you can build huge building and pay as much taxes as if you built a single family house, well, encouraging efficient use of land is the whole point.
Also, the current system is a subsidy from the dense neighborhoods, where the tax base is at, to edges of the city, where the city spends more of public funds per inhabitant. If people had to pay for their own road, water and power line, there would have been much less sprawl.
"You say your central NYC land is worth $1? Unfortunately we have to acquire it under eminent domain, but we'll pay you 1000x the value, a whole $1000!"