I think otherwise trying to be a "senior generalist" or "staff generalist" is going to be very hard, but for logical reasons.
I think otherwise trying to be a "senior generalist" or "staff generalist" is going to be very hard, but for logical reasons.
You have to know what you're talking about and know when to defer to experts, and being a generalist might prepare you well for that. But once you've reached the threshold on knowledge and critical thinking, the biggest barrier to being a good manager is mastering the mechanics of people wrangling.
Firstly, besides understanding the work, a manager also has to be able to actually manage subordinates. This is orthogonal to technical ability. Secondly, internal promotion of a generalist carries risk of that generalist being too opinionated based on his own work. They are much more likely to be a conservative force. This might be an unnecessary barrier to good changes.
These days I try to just be a tie-breaker for the team, instead of laying out the plan and looking for "feedback".