1) Collect only the data strictly necessary for the functioning of the service. If you suffer a data breach, you used security best practices, and notified the corresponding authorities and your users in due time, then you shouldn't be punished at all, with very few exceptions. If you didn't use best security practices, you may see some small to moderate fines, depending on each case.
2) Collect whatever you want (while still mentioning it in your Privacy Policy, and the whole thing). But if you suffer a data breach, and that data is exposed, you should need a big fat banking account to survive the fine that will be imposed on you. The fines should be big enough that they should deter even the big players from collecting too much of the data they don't need.