> To me, even with super short lines, braces at the end of the line are messy, and consistently messy is still messy.
To me, they're just harder to spot. I think having them on their own line "frames" the inner block nicely.
That said, brace location is not the hill I'm willing to die on. It's a minor thing, not worth getting religious over. For my own code, I'll do it how I want. For a team, though, consistency really does matter. I'll make my case, and then I'll shut up and do what the group decides.
(And actually, I think consistency within a file matters more than consistency between files, so I'm fine with "The file author/main maintainer sets the style for the file. If you modify the file, keep the existing style.")