I think that going to school should still be seen as an investment, just a more reasonable one. If getting a degree won't help you get a job, I don't think the government should be fully paying for it - you should have to make financial sacrifices too. I guess mostly I just don't want to be the one paying (through taxes) for useless degrees that don't help the economy/employment, maybe that makes me selfish but it's my opinion.
I guess americans have the same stance against social healthcare: "Why should I pay for the sickness of other people ?"
I think it is indeed selfish, but the US culture has been nurtured like this since it's inception.
Because students then value their education and also try to get into majors that bring more value to the society.
Granted, the latter assumes that value to the society correlates with future earnings, which may not always be the case.