Am I placing too much faith in reason?
An issue I take with Sam's initial argument is that it seemed to imply that it is not possible to tell the progressive and regressive apart.
Am I placing too much faith in reason?
An issue I take with Sam's initial argument is that it seemed to imply that it is not possible to tell the progressive and regressive apart.
Unless we can reason our way through ideas, what hope is there that we can find our way out of a paper bag?
If an idea is universally considered regressive, then usually it doesn't come up. Ideas that people are discussing are usually ones where it's not completely clear yet, to everyone, whether it is a good idea or not. In that case, allowing both sides fair advocacy is critical to making a fair decision.
If we can’t agree that there exist regressive ideas, what are we even doing here?
I haven’t stated what I believe to be progressive or regressive. You don’t know what viewpoints I hold. I have withheld these viewpoints from the discussion precisely because I am trying to establish agreement regarding some basic, primitive notions.
And just what are those ideas? I'm guessing not everyone will agree to them.
> I haven’t stated what I believe to be progressive or regressive. You don’t know what viewpoints I hold.
It doesn't matter. My point is not everyone will agree with your viewpoints.
How do you propose we move forward?
How do we move forward? Do we go straight ahead? Well, dictatorship is always moving straight ahead, because they can easily define what is progressive and what is regressive, by looking at the dictator. If progressiveness and regressiveness is so easy to define, what do we even need democracy for? Let's just find the most progressive person and appoint him our president/prime minister/chariman/king/chieftain, and let him lead us forward.
Of what intellectual value is common belief?
It’s more worthwhile to anchor the discussion sub specie aeternitatis.