Fakespot was being criticized above because the person claims they misjudged his wife's book reviews while also revealing that his wife was conducting the very behavior Fakespot is designed to detect. Whether the biased reviewers volunteer or were asked is completely besides the point.
Look at it from a consumer's point of view, volunteer, paid, or asked the result is the same. The reviews are at best biased and may even be fake (depending on if they actually read the book, and would have given it less than five stars under any circumstances).
The other sense is one of a natural human (but honest) response of friends excited by the celebrity status of one of their own.
I agree fully with your comment on the consumer's point of view, though. As a consumer that point's not lost on me.
She comes to get to know her best fans. They leave honest reviews on their own accord.
This is NOT her asking for random friends and family to leave a positive review. I wasn't clear before.