He would tell you that NPS is only like earnings or revenues if we allowed either to have 50% or more of their data filled with arbitrary numbers, not audited data collected from state-licensed specialists who would lose their job if it was discovered the data was manufactured whole cloth.
The author would also tell you that NPS is easily gamed and there's no checking on whether that is or not. He wrote extensively in the article the various techniques that folks can game the numbers. If this is a number reported to shareholders, shareholders should insist (No, Demand!) that the numbers be corroborated by a neutral third party that will accept liability for any errors. (No surety insurer will guarantee such a liability, for the risk of error or misrepresentation is way too high.)
As you stated, most use follow-up questions to get a richer understanding of the customer. What the author would tell you is that it's clear the NPS recommendation question taints those followup questions and diminishes their validity and inherent value. If the true goal is to learn a richer understanding of customer experience, there are many better ways to achieve it.
In other words, the author believes if executives want a simple metric that is better than NPS, a random number generator is the fastest and cheapest way to achieve it. Why bother with customers at all, if all you're going to do is squander your interaction with them on such a foolish metric.
— The author.