I second the open source suggestion.
I second the open source suggestion.
And where did the 2:1 ratio come from? It takes decades to become a surgeon. It takes maybe 20 minutes of training someone to mop a floor.
The market does regulate these things normally, if there's no coercion. That's why socialist countries are oppressive, to enforce a vision that goes against the will of some individuals, to the benefit of other individuals.
You can't have freedom if you refute freedom of choice.
If you or anyone else has ideas on that, please share them :)
Here's a better example, a worker-owned engineering and manufacturing cooperative in Wisconsin: http://www.isthmuseng.com/company/worker-owned-cooperative/
...interestingly, they specialize in automation equipment.
The way to make it possible to pay everyone well is to use automation. The only way to achieve that shiny Star Trek future is through replicators (which are a stand-in for general automation tech), although you could always be like the Ferengi and charge for use of the replicator... Tech ENABLES high wages even for janitors, but it doesn't guarantee it. That requires an actual choice.
I think co-ops are the best approach right now to shifting our economy in a direction that is fair and equitable, rather than the capitalist economy of exploitation we are stuck with now.
1. Why should the newly hired janitor have equal voting rights to the CTO that envisioned and built the product or the Machine Learning PHD whose education cost him 10 years and half a million dollars?
2. Personnel counts grow at an exponential rate. If you double your personnel count over a year as plenty of startups do, what's stopping all the new employees from mutinying and kicking out the early employees that have been been working on the business for 5 years?
3. Where's the incentive for founders who face disproportionate risk in the startup stage to build an enterprise that they may eventually own 0.1% of?
If you have ever even thought of starting a business on your own, you would not think this is a good idea.
2. See my point on 1. In the long term however, the kind of mutiny you suggest could be a good and necessary thing. In a co-op, you are not starting "your" company, but a cooperative. The whole point is that it is owned and run by everyone, it's not the founder's special baby. If the founder can't see what's best for the company and its workers while everyone else can, then they should definitely be overruled.
3. The incentive is to be founding something that can change the exploitative nature of the economy we live in. You're not starting a co-op to get rich off the work of others in implementing your amazing idea for an ice-cream delivery app. You're making a product that a community is invested in, both in the production and consumption, where everyone truly benefits because they all have a share of power over the project. A co-op couldn't buy up entire city blocks because one small board decided on it, or pollute a water supply because one small group of investors didn't give a fuck. That is why we need co-ops.
I've been involved with starting businesses and I think co-ops are great.
Maybe there's opportunity there. An open question to all: What are some challenges with starting and managing co-op businesses?
The reason why a single vote per person is fine is that more senior employees also have more influence in the organization just naturally. They can and will be able to persuade people, as long as they're doing their job effectively. Also, there can be a fairly long (months or years) on-boarding process where employees learn the culture and values of the organization.
If you are doing such a crappy job that you can't even convince the janitor that you know what you're doing, then I fail to see why you deserve a bunch of extra votes.
...and if your machine learning PhD cost you half a million dollars, I suggest you should get a refund. That's ridiculous.
Wrong usage of "exponential" seems to grow exponentially these days.
...but that's hardly responsive to the topic at hand.