If you're using java, just use finagle's http server and be done with it. It is really good and runs most all of twitter.com's production web services. The very definition of "web scale":
Twitter, Soundcloud, Salesforce, Pinterest, FitBit, Tumblr, Box, Foursquare... What do they all have in common? They all run finagle in production. For java, it is about as battletested and as good as you'll get unless you want to write your own. Personally, I'm more of a golang and python developer, but respect where it is due. Twitter is massively more scalable than the overwhelmingly majority of the sites on the internet and they've gotten their act together since abandoning Ruby and the fail whale.
Pick two.