/apologies for reddit style
/apologies for reddit style
I played football all through middle school and high school, and was fairly good. When you are playing as a kid, unless you are extremely elite, you aren't thinking about the NFL and potentially hitting your head hundreds of times into NFL sized players. You are just having fun and playing a sport. Then maybe you start getting good and someone tells you if you get a bit bigger and faster you might be able to go to college for FREE! You think, "no one in my family has ever been able to go to college!" Suddenly that sport-for-fun becomes just a means to an end that you never thought was possible.
So you work your ass off, get really good and college recruiters start showing up to games. You know they are there and this is your chance to shine. So you run extra fast, hit extra hard, you aren't showing any mercy to your opponents and you certainly aren't thinking about your brain at age 40. Maybe you get hit a bit hard and feel like you need to throw up. Your coach knows about the recruiters also, so he helps you hide the fact that you threw up. He stands in front of you pretending to talk to you while you bend slightly and puke in a water cup. You aren't thinking about brain injury, you are thinking about not showing weakness in front of these people.
Now MAYBE you are the ~1% that gets a full ride scholarship. You are playing college ball on a scholarship and you know the only reason you can stay in school and finish a degree is if you stay on the starting squad. You aren't staying on that squad as a linebacker unless you are ignoring your own personal safety.
MAYBE you are again the ~1% that make it the four years and are maybe good enough for the NFL. You can either say "nah, I'm good with my accounting degree" or you can see the potential to make more money on one signing day than your entire family has made in all of their lives combined!
I can keep going, but I hope people get the point. When millions of kids start playing football in 6th grade (12 years old), them and their parents weren't thinking about the potential they'd ever be "mashing your head into the helmet of a 300lb person" in the future.
As a parent now, me and my friends are thinking about that now. For some players (like the one in the article) it is 30 years too late.
This however, is one of them. I really do think it's that simple. The sport itself is flawed in design.
I have not seen any meaningful change from the NFL (or CFL, haha) to specifically combat this risk. I think they know the game is exciting because of these brutal impacts, and they're afraid to water it down and risk profits just to protect the (expendible) players.
Wow this place is turning into WaPo.
Football is a twentieth-century technological struggle.
Football is played on a gridiron, in a stadium, sometimes called Soldier Field or War Memorial Stadium.
Football begins in the fall, when everything's dying.
In football you wear a helmet.
Football has hitting, clipping, spearing, piling on, personal fouls, late hitting and unnecessary roughness.
Football is rigidly timed, and it will end even if we've got to go to sudden death.
n football the object is for the quarterback, also known as the field general, to be on target with his aerial assault, riddling the defense by hitting his receivers with deadly accuracy in spite of the blitz, even if he has to use shotgun. With short bullet passes and long bombs, he marches his troops into enemy territory, balancing this aerial assault with a sustained ground attack that punches holes in the forward wall of the enemy's defensive line.
The health aspects of this are the most urgent, but I'd argue that as coaches and analysts have developed algorithms to optimize very particular strategies, they've also squeezed much of the fun out of the game. I wrote about this elsewhere:
----------------------
Watching professional sports has become less fun over the last 50 years, due to athletes improving while the rules of most games have gone largely unchanged. Basketball players are taller, on average, than 60 years ago, yet the height of the basket has not been raised. Tennis players have learned to optimize techniques for smashing serves, which often leads to boring games where everything is decided by the strength of a player's serve -- obviously tennis is more fun to watch when there is a long and dramatic volley. American football has seen a relative improvement in defense, such that some games are just 3 attempts at 10 yards, then punt, followed by 3 attempts at 10 yards, then punt, followed 3 attempts at 10 yards, then punt. I'm not exaggerating, I actually saw a game in December where there was something like 5 punts in 5 minutes of play action. Who wants to watch that? In the specific case of American football, an obvious change that could be made is to allow 5 or 6 attempts to get 10 yards, instead of 4. That would be fun, I love watching the pass or run plays, much more than the punts. I learned to love football when I was a little kid, because my older brother loved football and I liked to watch the games with him. Back then I remember many long, dramatic passes, of a type that have become rare as defense has gotten relatively better at stopping exactly that strategy. But whenever I explain to people that the rules of sports need to be often updated to keep up with changes in equipment and training regimes, I'm told that any change would render historical comparisons invalid. Obviously that is true, but what is more important, that we are able to compare today's game to a game in 1956, or that the game is fun?
http://www.smashcompany.com/philosophy/am-i-completely-insan...
When I was playing years ago, it was called, "getting your bell rung." It was a temporary problem like getting a muscle cramp or something.
I call BS on your clairvoyance.
Did you make that reasoning up? Guess we should only have one study for anything, because any successive studiers means the first one wasn't good enough for them.
There's already been studies that showed repeated low impact hits on the head (ala soccer) create a deficit in cognitive ability in young people - http://www.cnn.com/2017/02/14/health/brain-damage-dementia-c...
The only reason to keep asking for more studies is to stall so they can make money off of high school athletes, high school football in Texas in a racket as documented in the book Friday Night Lights (not the movie or TV show). Also, if you don't believe that book, James Michener wrote a book 20 years earlier called Sports in America that documents the same phenomena across America in all amateur athletics.
Also I grew up in Texas and no matter how podunk the town was, they spent bank on high school football stadiums then and tens of millions now. You wouldn't understand this if you dont know this.