Famine, war and poverty is nothing new either. Neither is social collapse for that matter.
About 65% of all US Government spending is going to entitlements at this point. ~80% is going to entitlements + welfare programs. That percentage will continue to increase over the next decade. At the current rate of growth, entitlement spending alone will consume all US Government spending in about 30 years. Entitlement, welfare programs, and defense spending are basically crowding out all other government spending, pushing the "other" spending toward an ever smaller share of the budget (which is why US infrastructure is in such desperate need of investment).
You can certainly argue we need to be a lot smarter in our spending allocation. The biggest problem the US has is not that it isn't spending, it's that the cost of these systems is astronomically out of line with what is actually sustainable (eg the US healthcare system at all levels).
Source?
> About 65% of all US Government spending is going to entitlements at this point
Source? And does this include military?
> At the current rate of growth, entitlement spending alone will consume all US Government spending in about 30 years
Source? And is this just the "current rate of growth" frozen in place or does it take into account ways that that rate of growth has been changing as well?
24% = Social Security
26% = Medicare/Medicaid/CHIP/Affordable Care Act
9% = Other Safety Net programs ex-SS/Medicare
8% = Benefits for federal retirees + veterans
That's 67% right there.Other significant spending:
16% = Defense
6% = Interest on debt
2% = Transportation/Infrastructure
2% = Education
2% = Science and medical research
The federal government took in $3.3 trillion and spent $3.9 trillion, so $0.6 trillion borrowed, which is almost our entire defense budget.To balance the budget, you'd need to take out 15 percentage points from the categories above, or increases taxes by ~$4,600 per US household (or a combination of the two).
[0] https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-budget/policy-basics-w...
The fact that congress borrows from the fund and doesn’t pay it back is a problem with the rest of the budget, not social security.
It seems like there is something similar going on with the debate over healthcare. People on the right seem to conceive of the healthy and the sick as separate classes of people. But I don't, so arguments based on an inherent struggle between the two are not sensical to me.
It almost seems as if the much older view of the rich and poor as separate classes has metastasized and mutated across ideological boundaries.
Also, the person who provided the source was someone else, so if you're asking for a source re my question, perhaps someone will provide it. In any case your poke got me wondering and doing a bit of research.
Perhaps the reason this feels off is because it's the government budget, which is a subset of the overall economy obviously. And, a lot of the dollars spent here are going back into corporations, for varying levels of return on the dollar I'm sure. I think this is why the numbers sound so great/generous, but don't match reality when you look out the window, watch the news, or read the newspaper.
This 16% ($605 billion) number includes $74 billion in a special Overseas Contingency Operations bill for Afghanistan.
Alternatively, you may also be thinking of the DoD ‘black budget’, which is classified. That is included in the budget, but it’s not itemized or described in any way to keep what it’s spent on a secret. It’s typically around $65 billion.
The way it's organised now is that your government gives the poorest some money while the rich complain incessantly, then the rich siphon it off for themselves.
Only if your laws allow for "ridiculously high insurance costs". Caps exist for a reason.
OK, I don't disagree with what you're saying necessarily, but I'm not convinced that social welfare is by any means biggest way we're wasting money, nor that it's necessarily causing some huge social dysfunction that would magically fix itself if we "trimmed the bloat". I think it's just hard for a lot of people to procure enough resources to comfortably live in this society, so we have to decide how to best deal with that.
> Get rid of the rich-person welfare
Great idea. How do you propose to do that?
> your government gives the poorest some money ..., then the rich siphon it off for themselves.
Sadly, unlike other manufacuring industries, LockHead and Boeing can’t just develop random defense products and then let governments buy them (regular annunitions are okay). If that was the case, then DoD would be a client rather than both the client and the project management. Instead, we as client lets Boeing builds the fighting jets, and DoD sells them to foreign countries.
The waste could have been invested in veteran service, healthcare, national infrastructure (bridges, highways, dams, power grids), and whatnot. Politicans are scared to cut DoD’s budget because in America we are so supportive of our troops, many get upset when DoD budget is reduced for cleaning up unnecessary projects.
[1]: http://thehill.com/opinion/finance/373136-congress-just-agre...
[2]: https://amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/mar/20/pentag...
[3]: http://amp.washingtontimes.com/news/2017/mar/7/us-military-w...
[4]: http://www.industryweek.com/companies-executives/lockheed-sa...
The US military itself is a social welfare program. It provides millions of Americans with a job.
this is cutting edge, high risk technology bet, nobody in the world built something like that on such huge scale, it is expected to have problems in such projects. But what is the alternative?
This means that there will be less disability and worker’s compensation social assistance.
Additionally, there may be less disability and worker's compensation but there will be more costs due to poverty. Homeless people cost society far more money than working people.
I've often heard supporters of that so-called fallacy invoke the idea of humans maintaining and repairing robots. That's a pretty weak argument. Warren Bennis has the right of it:
The factory of the future will have only two employees, a man and a dog. The man will be there to feed the dog. The dog will be there to keep the man from touching the equipment.
Now we are building AI (mechanical minds). Is there any reason to believe AI won't eventually replace humans for all mental tasks? I can't see one.
It's unrealistic to think we can simulate something we don't understand. BTW the same rhetoric was being said in the 80's regarding expert systems, as what folks are saying today about deep learning. In the former case expectations exceeded the result, and we got a decade long "AI winter". Why should this time be any different?
IMO AI won't be capable of replacing humans for centuries, maybe millennia. I predict we'll progressively automate more and more routine activities via AI, freeing humans to focus on more creative / higher value activities while being more efficient. We got the same deal from the Industrial Revolution, which also brought us the vast levels of prosperity we enjoy today.
It's only going to take a few percentage points at the bottom of the income scale to create a crisis. Heck, we're already seeing that in countries like Greece and Spain. It's a cascade effect.
If we don't solve the problems created by structural unemployment then we'll see our society collapse long, long before we see the very last job automated by AI.