There are tons of similar best practice inefficient solutions to society's problems in order to deal with the malicious actors because nobody has solved this problem and I doubt anyone ever will.
Do you have an idea for how to stop people from acting maliciously? Considering how subjective that question is, I cannot think of one (for a democracy at least).
Yes,cultural homogeneity results in lower overall levels of malicious actors and free riders.
However, in the USA the only way to get such homogeneity is to (a) wait a long time for communications and migration to turn soften differences or (b) create a culture out of whole cloth, and use propaganda to spread it to the young.
[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/reply?id=16410740&goto=threads%...
If everyone took your approach we would end up as a sharply segregated society where the public domain becomes the preserve of 'malicious actors' and those without the ability to avoid it. That would be a classic dystopia. These places exist. Seattle should not be one of them. Better to stand your ground in the public domain despite the risks. Your presence will make it a better and safer place for everyone.
When you frame it like that, isn't that kind of what it has already become? Cities are full of crime so people with money move to the suburbs where it is safer.
There is probably a name for this phenomenon. It's a sort of reverse tragedy of the commons.
> Cities are full of crime so people with money move to the suburbs where it is safer.
I think this was happening most in the middle of last century. Now, inner-city areas around the world are being gentrified by wealthy people that (I believe) recognise the lack of communal life afforded by suburbs - things such as the day to day passing of friends and strangers in the street, at the local cafe or shops, and a generally higher level of engagement that's possible when you spend less of your 'public' time in a vehicle.
Public transport does not work, and this is just one more reason why. Every few years the police feels the need to spend a month or two catching pickpockets (or worse) on public transport. Train stations in all the big cities are hotbeds of criminal activity. That is a major problem that is not, and probably won't ever be, solved.
For me personally public transport fails in 3 massive ways:
1) public transport means I cannot do groceries, shopping for furniture, tvs or other big goods, move houses, ... so I still need a car, public transport or not.
2) governments just don't build out public transport. Even in places with "excellent" public transport, when I pass there (the Netherlands, for example), there are severe capacity problems that COULD have been solved, but aren't.
In many places like London or New York, there aren't capacity problems, you're actually unlikely to NOT be delayed at some point.
3) it's not actually cheaper once you take into account that you have to bring 2 kids to school, then go to work. Taking the cost/inconvenience/risk of public transport doesn't even provide a monetary or time reward.
This also means that using public transport for family trips is out : driving across Europe (e.g. Netherlands -> South of France) for a weekend or holiday ... train is a LOT more expensive than using a car.
(That said, it can provide a big time advantage and I will use it in that case, but I still much prefer a car)
Some reading on the subject:
http://www.uwgb.edu/DutchS/PSEUDOSC/MassTransit.HTM
https://www.forbes.com/sites/jeffmcmahon/2013/03/06/top-eigh...
I've never had a car and moved place many times, yes it means hiring a man with a van, but my things wouldn't fit in a car anyway.
I haven't seen much crime in stations apart from fare dodging, yes there might be pickpockets, but probably not more than other places outside in London. You're pretty safe, there is good lighting and staffing and cameras everywhere.
Those things can be delivered. Often for free, almost always for less than it would cost to park a car in a city for a single month.
> move houses
You can't do that in a normal sized car. Are you suggesting that every person should own their own truck? Unless you are moving every month it makes more sense just to rent one.
For whom? Works surprisingly well for my family aside from the 23 going from Manhattan into Brooklyn on the weekends.