The Verge's argument is that because they have a chin at the bottom, the notch is purely cosmetic since they didn't utilize the space at the bottom. I find this argument to be poor reasoning. Moving to a notch at the top seems like an inevitable future for most smartphones - we need an earpiece as well as front facing cameras and other sensors, either we at a top chin, or we notch. Those are the options. The notch just means we have additional usable screen space and creates a more full screen experience. By moving to a notch now it means that more android phones can start practicing for that future design, rather than pushing it off to avoid looking like they're copying apple (despite android doing it first with the essential phone). Eventually that chin at the bottom will be screen as well, but that won't be a change to usability like having the notch is. I think Asus is smart moving forward with this despite the strange publicity that they probably expected it would get (such as this article). This seems like less a design issue or an aspect of one company copying another, and more like just The Verge trying to write something that will generate clicks.