I'm a fan of co-ops, but gave up on the idea of replacing the private sector with it. If there's a market for them, they can compete easily (usually through quality). I'm inclined to see them as better agents for social welfare programs [1].
I'd like to hear from the author why they focus on some (in foreign eyes) romantic region in Italy and don't look at the dryer examples of large-scale co-ops that exist throughout the rest of Europe:
Germany's and Switzerland's biggest retailers are co-ops (Rewe, Edeka and Migros, Coop). Italy's biggest retailer is also a co-op. German co-op retail-banks claim 20% market share. Austria's Reiffeisen Bank is the country's third largest bank. The world's biggest sugar-producer Südzucker is a co-op. The list of old co-ops that have scaled over time is long and studying them I think would provide much needed insight if we are to claim the "advancedness" of co-ops.
Specifically all the scandals that have popped-up, like the "co-op-Scandal" of the late 1980s, one of Germany's biggest cases of financial fraud.
[1] For example don't let the city/state build cheap housing, rather subsidize housing co-ops. Once you do that, you get political entanglement in return and in general the imbalance of the private-sector being marginalized. But I prefer that anytime over government housing. Germany is full of both (co-ops and city-run housing, with the latter being usually run-down and the former trumping median private-sector housing while being 30%++ cheaper).