Public sector inefficiency is well studied. Co-ops efficiency however not so much, at least for me.
Public sector inefficiency is well studied. Co-ops efficiency however not so much, at least for me.
Attempt at answering: Co-ops try to provide affordable quality housing thus gains are usually reinvested via repair work and they don’t engage in selling their housing stock on the free market. Property they built, usually stays theirs forever. I think the biggest leverage on prices comes from land allocated to them by a city. As most shareholders are also renters they push the co-op leadership into keeping rents low and over time prices can diverge quite a lot from free market rates.
I don't see the lower returns as particularly damaging - there has been too much speculation in real state in recent decades. But that might not be the case once (if) returns get lower.
Now technically you could argue that the outcome would be the same if you lived more expensively and you were an investor in some other for-profit housing with high returns. But that’s usually not the case, as the cash amounts you’d need initially are too high for most people.
There are also private housing stock examples for that behaviour: gentrification theory sees the so-called "pioneers" who move into low-quality neighbourhoods. They are doing much of the work improving quality-of-live/attractiveness that later on others will reap the benefits from like real-estate developers and long-time landlords.