The claimed advantages of systemd are mostly relevant, IMHO, for mobile devices that change configuration often. It brings no particular advantage to servers or desktops, unless you tend to swap out lots of peripherals on your desktop.
The disadvantages are partially political -- systemd tries to take over every job it can; the originator has made it clear that his vision is for every system function to be handled by systemd -- and partially philosophical: it used to be the case that most subsystems were independent of each other, so that they could be replaced more or less easily if the sysadmin had different needs.
The current stable Debian still makes it possible to run a different init system with just a line of package installation and a reboot.