But what bothers me, is I keep asking myself the question: When and why did we decide to give the proxy all the power in this relationship?
If we have to use proxies, at least the proxy should be transparent about itself to all parties on the connection. Then my bank can drop the connection or restrict functions/data to non-proxied data, secure government servers can drop the connection, my browser can drop the connection and give me an error (because I don't want anyone snooping on my banking history), etc.
Eg. Let's say I open the patient portal for my hospital through a proxy. Is the proxy software HIPAA compliant? What about the people that have access to my health data through the proxy software? In this case, I would think we should allow the portal software to drop the connection because the connection itself is not secure.