FDIC, as the underwriter, has the power not to insure a manifestly poorly-run bank. Thus, the FDIC mark is a defacto sign that a bank can be trusted by a consumer.
I would much rather have FDIC (or a system of robust private bank insurance) than need to vet each prospective bank's balance sheet, employees, and loans when choosing to open a personal checking account.
Responding to below:
>>Successfully rescuing a bank from a run is not only a benefit to society as a whole but often makes a small net profit.
This is the free lunch fallacy used to justify involuntary income redistribution. If it were indeed profitable on average, the market would do the bailing out.
Bailing out the irresponsible prevents the evolutionary process of weeding out reckless and incompetent business models and behavioural patterns from working, while unfairly burdening those who are competent in their management of capital, which inhibits the expansion of their influence.