Seems to me employees "are likely to walk out the door" mainly because employers view them as expendible expenses and not humans trading labor for something of value
Nobody these days would turn down a $10k raise out of company loyalty. They might for other reasons, but loyalty is absolutely not one of them anymore.
Its stupid to spend the $20k, figure its "done" and then think you can just go on paying the $50k after the fact even though the employee is clearly now worth $70k.
You want a $70k talent, you can either find one straight up or make one with some mix of lower salary + training until you have one.
If you hire someone for $50k, then train them with $20k, then give them a raise after the training is over for the $20k it takes to bring their comp up to market, you're out $90k. Accounting-wise, you just gifted the employee $20k on top of his comp.
Or you can just go out and hire for $70k and just be out $70k. This is what's already being done, shifting the cost of training and education onto the ones receiving the benefits of that training.
I'm trying hard to not post a diatribe about what's wrong with this kind of thinking and just point out the errors in reasoning that come from it, but this game of whack-a-mole is frustrating. You can't demand your employer to shoulder all the risks and grant unto you all the rewards. It's unethical and leads to underhanded dealing. We want a more professional labor marketplace, not one governed by promises and half-truths.
Final answer, then I'm getting back to work. Because when you take risks, you should expect a reward. If your reward isn't worth the risk, but you still take it anyway, then you're the dumb one. When you're the one offering liquid compensation, you get to decide on the risk profile of the bought solution.
Isn't the whole point of taking a risk is that there may not actually be any reward? If you expect reward every time then it's not really a risk.
e.g. if a company invests in a building for their office, there's always a risk that building will incur excessive maintenance expenses, become unusable because of some calamity, or that the location around the building will become a bad neighborhood and make that building a lot less useful.
i think a company can invest in, say, teaching their employees a valuable skill and then make money off that investment, even if the employee leaves eventually.
the distinction you raise is that there (apparently) is no such thing as an insurance policy that protects a company against a valuable employee's departure.
but that doesn't mean "invest" is the wrong word to use when a company spends money to educate an employee.
also, there are strategies aside from a literal insurance policy which companies can and do use to increase employee retention rates. (just like there are strategies other than insurance policies that companies can use to protect a building against damage or loss of value.)
You seem to be equating bets with gambling for some reason.
Yeah good luck with that.
1. Pay them more money.
2. Give them interesting things to work on.
3. Invest in their career development.
...
It isn't "luck". Many companies just suck at that (either because they have bad leadership or their industries don't support it).
Also the expected rewards are higher too. If a company bets $20k in an employee, the best they can hope for is that the employee does a good job. Not that that bet doubles in value.
What do you think it means from the company's perspective to "do a good job"? A developer who does a good job will most likely double that $20k in a few months.
Pro athletes are a terrible example. There has been decades of litigation, lockouts, negotiations, etc. across almost all leagues to get to where we are now and there are many that continue to think the system is too restrictive for the players and too much in a league's favor.
There might be some legal barriers to this problem like recovering the investments when the employee breaks the contract? Seems like some kind of insurance would help there, though.
Seems to work fine for athletes, actors, medical residents, certain kinds of scholarships, etc.
Any place I work, it’s easier to train my replacement than it was to train me. It allows me to pick up new projects or leave for a more interesting opportunity without guilt.
Work yourself out of a job.
It definitely means I’m easier to lay off. But I’ve survived 2 rounds of layoffs before and buddy, if you can figure out how to pay your mortgage without a front row seat to watch a company crumble around you then I highly recommend it. (Also only the 1st round offers a decent severance package, and survivor guilt is no fun).
Personal finances help with that. As do maintaining relationships with people.