Please also check Zircon's kernel license [2]. The PATENTS thing doesn't look though.
Or did you meant that it doesn't have a GNU license with a clause that forces others to distribute the source?
Probably it doesn't matter that much to them as by being the developers of the software they can make changes in their software and just not share it.
Anyway, I'm not happy with more Googlification and them having the "expertise monopoly" in yet another piece of tech.
Things like ChromeOS and Chromecast shows that they're not willing to create an open OS.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Fuchsia [2] https://fuchsia.googlesource.com/zircon/+/master/LICENSE
If Fuchsia shipped on phones in binary form, consumers receiving those phones would have no legal basis for requesting the source code of precisely what they received.
GPL-compatibility only speaks to the mixing of code having one license with GPL code.
Of course a non GPL license would put us in a worse position but the current situations also has limitations.
I wonder if GNUv3 could solve the blobs drivers issue.
Not to mention that the fat profits capitalism bestows on Google FUNDS fuchsia
Did you drop an /s or something?
Captialism doesn't give a shit about eithics or merit either way. The only thing worth a damn is capital, which is a pretty good motivator for all kinds of unethical and corrupt practices.
Not that GPL would necessarily be a good thing in this case.
That's the point (or at least one of them). Though I personally don't care if it is GPL or not, as someone interested in perhaps using this OS for commercial purposes at some point it's not being GPL is a slight plus for me.
However, one key point of the GPL is to create a commons (of software, hardware, protocols, etc.) that can't be exploited for gain by capitalists, that can't be exploited for economic rent, that can't be laden down with copyrights and patents. A system that is actually, truly free (as in freedom). Which is important to understand if you want to be intellectually honest.
> Capitalism is an ethical, meritorious system rewarding hard-work
Um... no it isn't. Meritorious only for those on top. While I agree that Google doesn't need to GPL Fuschia, GPL was imagined as a direct response capitalism's very pro-owner and anti-customer approach to distribution and rightsholding.Nothing forces anyone from using someone else's GPL software. You aren't prevented from using GPL software either. In fact, it has a price, and that price is you contributing changes and directly interfaced software back into GPL. The price isn't money.
Beyond this, open-source/floss is meant to create a commons in terms of libraries and software that aren't commercially encumbered. Way too many things (particularly drivers) are locked away and stop working.
As a point of fact, it doesn't. Stallman himself sold GNU Emacs in the early days, and it was GPL'd from the start.
Capitalism is not "the economic system in which things are bought and sold with money", it's a much more particular subset of all those types of economies (namely, capitalism is the type where the primary resources and means of production are privately owned).
It's incidentally TRUE that GPL is not anti-capitalist. But it's also true that you can consistently both sell things and be anti-capitalist. Selling things happens in most economic systems, capitalist or not.
Well, at least according to Marx (c.f. Capital) capitalism is the system where things are bought and sold with money. If you read first few chapters of Capital you'll see that Marx explains this in various ways such as characterizing capitalism with division of labour where instead of producing bunch of commodities, workers produce one commodity and sell it for money with which they can buy other commodities. And according to, again, his definition communism is the society after this type of commodity production, i.e. the mechanism that produces value (money) is stopped in the sense that people stopped exchanging things for money.
You may not care of Marx's definition, but I just wanted to note for completeness.
We can describe the idea of buying and selling with money as certainly being a characteristic of Capitalism without asserting that it's a defining characteristic that is absent in other systems.
To be blunt, buying and selling with money is FAR older than Capitalism.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitalism is actually pretty good and neutral
Capital starts by explaining commodities. This is because: (1) Marx tries to explain some bit of the terminology of his period's economic terminology so he needs to do some ground work; (2) commodity production is an important aspect of capitalism that he refers all throughout his works. My main point is that the force that made capitalism possible and the force that sustains capitalism is one, which is the accumulation of value. As Marx explains in later chapters, a things will have different types of values. For Marx, nothing has any intrinsic value and its money-value is determined at the moment of trade. That is the force that generates value inside economy is the act of selling commodities. The same force causes the distinction between bourgeousie and prolateriat (c.f. Marx's definitions of social classes) and the same force caused the transformation from earlier economic system to capitalism (which answers your complaint). Now this brings us to the end of capitalism, which Marx very insistantly argues that end of capitalism is the seizure of value generation which is equivalent to saying society being moneyless. E.g. one misconception people have is that Marx was also against labor-vouchers, but this is not true, as explained in Critique of Gotha's Programme, since labor-vouchers do not generate/accumulate value, their value is not determined at the moment of trade. Anyway, this also relates to Marxist criticism of anarchism. For anarchism capitalism --> communism is the seizure of capitalist state. But Marxism thinks this is fundamentally wrong because capitalist state is generated by capitalist mode of production. So, you will want to eliminate the capitalist mode of production instead of the state itself, because as long as c.m.p exists there is no way to kill capitalism, so state will revive. For Marxism you first need to eliminate the economic system that makes capitalism possible, i.e. accumulation of value, and then ultimately kill the State and class society as they're caused by capitalism.
This belongs on some a list of "naive things Americans believe"