Others have been violating the guidelines in this thread too, but at least the other subthreads haven't gone completely out to the generic political sea.
Others have been violating the guidelines in this thread too, but at least the other subthreads haven't gone completely out to the generic political sea.
Your description of how we moderate HN isn't really accurate. When a story is nothing but partisan politics, we may kill the thread—though more often users flag it first—but those are just the easy cases. The difficult cases are when a story is both on topic for HN, like this one, but also has overlap into intensely political areas, like this one. Then our job becomes more fine-grained, trying to support thoughtful, specific discussion and dampen generic flamewars.
Yes, I imagine my comment might excite strong feelings more so than others - because such an atrocity does. For good reasons.
The discussion has clearly settled on the moral aspects of YC doing business in China. Which seems okay with you - as long as you don't call out the actual atrocities.
As is the fact that you're suppressing comments on these atrocities, which are far more extreme and less frequently discussed here than very tired US political wedge issues you disable flags on. This behaviour is a gross abuse of power.
You and your fellow VCs will make a fortune in the next few years. But blood will be on your hands, and it will harder to live with than you imagine. You already realize it on some level, albeit a deeply buried one.
http://www.theweek.co.uk/92884/which-country-executes-the-mo...