Hacker News Reader

Comment by reggieband | Hacker News Reader

I've heard from colleagues that this won't be possible with DASH due to the switch to fMP4 format. One of my co-workers tells me that fMP4 requires the entire segment to be loaded before playback can begin while TS segments don't require this. We've been looking into very small segments (e.g. 1s duration) to reduce latency but I've been interested in the LHLS approach since I first heard of it.

View on HN

> I've heard from colleagues that this won't be possible with DASH due to the switch to fMP4 format.

That's incorrect. With DASH the latency depends on the fragment duration, not the segment duration. You can start sending the segment when its first fragment is generated, and use chunk-based HTTP transfer as mentioned in other comments.

Link for further details on low latency: https://www.gpac-licensing.com/2014/07/09/lowering-dash-live...

Very short segment durations are effective only when latency is more important than quality.

Each TS segment must start with a key-frame, and the GOP size can't exceed the duration of a segment (e.g. one second). Lowering the segment duration increases the frequency of key-frames, which has the effect of lowering the quality you can achieve at a given bitrate.

Note that this is a Apple requirement for HLS. Most people don't realize that the GOP size doesn't impact the latency, but it impacts start-up time.

fMP4 has an index for each chunk, so you have to buffer the whole thing to create the index on the writing side. However, with DASH you do have the option for WebM as well, which does not need and index and can be streamed. Or really small fMP4 segments work too.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com