People are willing to pay Verizon prices for that guaranteed coverage. There are also places in north ga with bad coverage by T-mobile. They just happen to go out of their way to have coverage in college towns, but once you veer to far away - nothing.
The trade off is worth it for me, but not to other people.
The conventional wisdom is that Verizon has the best coverage, followed by AT&T, T-Mobile, and Sprint. But coverage is like politics -- everything is local. Or in this case, hyper-local.
For example, T-Mobile has outstanding coverage in the middle of the country thanks to its early acquisitions of PrimeCo and VoiceStream.
But I know a resort on the west coast where there is no Verizon, no AT&T, and no T-Mobile coverage. The only thing that connects is Sprint, because of an old Nextel tower in the middle of nowhere that was put in for the Forest Service back in push-to-talk days.