Themes by Woothemes are fantastic, but...aren't all website going to look the same?
I really like the way 37signals re-designed the Basecamp homepage. It's a little bit different than usual.
Yes. It is true. However, you can customize the theme any way you want to make it look unique. For $150 that's a deal... or you can spend $3000 for a "buyout" template from monster template (http://www.templatemonster.com/) and not even going to work with WordPress.