We have this with regular socket power too; if live and ground are shorted, connecting the device will shut off power to prevent the user from any harm due to a charged casing. There is no feedback other than "everything stopped working" because the GFI cannot tell if the situation is cleared without putting up power and potentially harming the user.
Think of the other scenario, the stimulator gets damaged, switches back on and kills the user. Pacemaker could do the exact same, if it's damaged it could kill the user very easily.
I was talking to a guy who's implanted defibrillator failed a while back.
It shorted out and started shocking him as fast as the capacitor(?) could recharge. It was shocking him, his nephew, the EMTs and ER staff until they finally got the thing shut off. His doctor was saying he's really, really lucky to be alive.
So, yeah, fail safe is good.
http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2012-03-28/health/sc-heal...
Really you want something like this to be as simple as possible without harming the patient.
A pacer is different than a brain stimulator. And pacers generally try to restart themselves if they can. Brain stimulators, because of the sensitivity of where you’re stimulating (a few cm, literally, away from regions that control breathing, heart rate, etc), the least risky option is a shut down.
How? Shock your brain? It's an implant.
> What if it had been a pacemaker or something?
The same question stands. How do you make the device provide reasonable feedback? Make your heart skip a few beats? How exactly is a pacemaker going to warn a user about an error condition?
Given the circumstances, and the rarity of the error case, it sounds like the device switching itself off is the best course of action.
Wow, now that is an interesting user interface.
Not sure why you'd assume the mainboard and peripheral circuit design on MacBooks would be particularly good, they seem to make the same mistakes for years on end.