When instead it is up for interpretation, that comes with issues. The first is selective enforcement, there is also the chilling effect on both sides. Those who ought to be protected worry about the slack given to their potential predators. Meanwhile those who are 'potential predators' need to worry about the slightest move that is illegal under some interpretation.
The end result of this chilling effect is fewer willing customers, fever willing companies, and less mutual trust. Notably, this lack of trust persists even if you presume everyone still follows the law. At that point it seems to me a law has failed.