>where Elsevier et al receive publicly-funded knowledge, yet privately control the supply.
But they are given the 'knowledge'. Sure, Chicken/Egg. Maybe government grants should come with a clause for open-access..
>where Elsevier et al receive publicly-funded knowledge, yet privately control the supply.
But they are given the 'knowledge'. Sure, Chicken/Egg. Maybe government grants should come with a clause for open-access..
They aren't because the journal corporations don't provide the curation, they provide the brand name that attracts heavy-hitting papers. The curation is provided by academics for free. The brand name ("impact factor" of historic papers in that journals) is the one thing that prevents migration.
I still think there should be some reform in this area but the journals do provide some value at the moment.
Yeah, I can see your point, but I think both can reasonably appear true: credentials are very 'sticky' concepts which seem reliable and are hard to dismiss unless everyone else is doing it too...
> Maybe government grants should come with a clause for open-access..
Hard agree.