Whichever fab produced it would have a huge hardware advantage in mining. They would mine themselves and just use 51% of their physical units (versus renting on a time-slot market) to do the attack.
Whichever fab produced it would have a huge hardware advantage in mining. They would mine themselves and just use 51% of their physical units (versus renting on a time-slot market) to do the attack.
The price-tank disincentive is multiplied by the block reward size -- the lower the reward, the the less the miner would care. The price-tank disincentive also is attenuated by future equilibrium mining. If you make the first ASIC and don't attack, future manufacturers will pop up as mining becomes more profitable. If you tank the price, mining profits may become low, but you thwart competition.
Attack gains are not connected strongly to the above disincentives. Attack gains are higher the more often you can cycle the coin -- you can actually steal way more than the market cap of the coin theoretically by cycling exchanges / other mechanisms of payment. Then you start running your 51% attack and reverse hours, days, weeks of transactions.
I see your point that there is some disincentive for a 51% attack, but I'm not sure that's enough.
This is exactly what they are doing.
Lots of people are buying GPUs, but any SINGLE gpu coin has a very small percentage of total GPU hashpower.
For the extreme case, image that I have GPU coin, but I am only supporting it with MY GPU.
That means that any other person in the world, can now attack my coin, if they have more GPUs than me (1).
The fact that lots of people own GPUs doesn't protect me, because those GPUs aren't contributing to the network!