Not necessarily disagreeing, but doesn't that basically invalidate the idea of a monopoly in a free and open internet? Perhaps the definition of a monopoly from analog era doesn't apply to the internet?
Maybe it would be true in a perfect free market, where people would act rational and won't be jerks,
I don't have proof but intuitively I can see a free market simulator where some actors will find a small loophole and exploit it to maximize it's profit destroying everyone else.
I would really love some economist to team up with some game developers and run some economic simulations with different level of regulations, it would be interesting to see how well the model would match the reality.