There are a ton of benefits to aws-vault. Strategically: getting everyone on an aws-vault workflow is step one to eventually making your IAM story great. We'll be publishing some general stuff about how we think you should start cleaning up your IAM story. We have Strong Opinions(TM) on how to get you from "bunch of people have * : * perms with keys they have on disk" to best-in-class, BeyondCorp-compliant temporary perms acquired on trustworthy endpoints.
(FWIW: also undersigned re: start by listening. Latacora starts with an audit too, but that feels like a cop-out answer :))