We don't drive (me or my partner), We recycle, I mend everything I can (which outside of a clean room is most things, it's never been easier with youtube), neither of use go in for excessive consumption (My current desktop is from 2011, it's finally coming up on time to replace that).
I even considered going vegetarian but with Crohn's that isn't really viable (I have to avoid high fibre and getting enough minerals/vitamins is a struggle).
We don't eat wild caught fish (or much fish at all).
I mean I'm not a tofu eating ecowarrior or anything but it just seems sensible not to piss in your own drinking water.
What to do about it would be for humans to effectively stop taking more from nature than we can give back. The tricky part would be to orchestrate that.
If you cut down your consumption but I won't it won't save the planet.
If I cut down my consumption but you won't it won't save the planet.
If you and I both did cut our consumption, the planet would begin to recover but then there would be someone else who starts taking what we chose not to take.
And because that someone would later have more than we, you and I would ourselves risk dying in resource wars that would likely follow.
This is basically what countries and continents do.
To make any difference it would take one powerful party who could hoard resources: just leave them unconsumed except for the amount needed to prevent others from consuming them. At the same time, they would keep others poor, or at least limiting their standard of living by denying resources from everyone. Assuming there was one ruler who could control the majority of the planet's resources that would still be an extremely hard position to be.
The other option is not to do anything and play along. When we out-consume and out-grow enough the population can't sustain itself and the headcount on this planet will shrink back to 50% or 30% of the current levels. Then the race begins again...
Here in Sweden it seems like most freshwater lakes suffer from overpopulation, and the commercial value of the fish is so little that the transportation cost to cat food factories makes it unprofitable to fish it. Making matters worse, overpopulation in lakes has a tendency to cause extinctions where some species crowds out others. There was/is some government initiative to fund fishing directly, but so far very few has taken up on the offer.
It is however quite hard to find a seller for this. Some restaurants has made a bit of PR from saying that they are serving this kind of fish, but I have never seen a menu with it or seen those species in any store. Your best bet would be to buy it directly from those fishing in the lakes which could be problematic depending on where you live.
"A true environmentalist may not birth or father their own children, only adopt."
RMS is famously known for refusing to own a cell phone until there's one that runs entirely on free software, what is at the same level of adherence for environmentalists?
Short of a massive population decrease, a complete switch in energy consumption, or some sci-fi type of technological breakthrough, we are doomed to run this planet into extinction.
At this point, most conservation efforts are more of a attempt to feel better as an individual then they are actually making a difference.
That doesn't mean we should stop, or concede, with our efforts. It just means we need to be realistic with what we do over the next 50-100 years.
Personally, I think the only way the human race will continue to thrive is to figure out how to survive without the Earth as a host. Whether we figure that out, or succumb to extinction, is really the ultimate test of our race. Were we designed to be a part of nature as it exists on Earth, or will we surpass it?
We know how to do these things, we know how to avoid the mistakes of the past. Yet we are not doing them. How do you propose getting the international community to do that work?
I'm more curious about what our path as a species will lead to - will we continuously innovate to survive on the planet we were given, or will we move past it? Both?
I don't think we're doomed.
Fixed that for you.
We're nothing more than an extremely specialized animal. What we do is (whether you like it or not) a product of nature. Our use of technology is just the large-scale version of a bird's nest, or an ant pile.
We've done far less damage than the asteroid that killed the dinosaurs. Deal with it.
Look at bacteria. They are also crazily adaptable. The do it by changing their DNA and a very high speed of generational change, and we use "culture" and "science" with longer individual lifespans.
Sorry, no. Please don't fix any more of my comments. That's really passive aggressive and demeaning and you can do better.
I really meant it. Under essentially any accounting system that is not human-centric at its core, we are really tops when it comes to destruction.
Birds and ants reach a natural equilibrium with their environment and end up as integral parts of a functioning ecosystem. Humans. Just. Don't. We nuke and pave. Stupidly. Overfishing is just one example, a tiny one. We exhaust all available resources in an area and if we're lucky enough to survive the inevitable ecosystem collapse that we leave in our wake, we move on, either up or out or over, and exhaust all of those resources, too.
If you really think we are equivalent to ants and birds, and we're just some kind of specialized animal, then I'm not sure we share the same basis for dialogue. Please step back from the personal afront that you feel by my comment and behold the destruction that humans have wrought. It is incalculable. There is a reason they are calling this the Anthropocene.
Cyanobacteria wiped out most other species on earth: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxygenation_Event
Birds caused mass extinctions and extreme evolutionary pressures: https://news.ucsc.edu/2012/06/giant-insects.html
Trilobites - one of the most diverse, plentiful, and advanced forms of life at the time - went extinct thanks to the evolution of plants.
If you take a snapshot during any of those events, a brief glimpse, sure those events were cataclysmically destructive. But step back and those events can instead be seen as fantastically creative.
It is anthropocentric to view the preservation of the ecological status quo and cessation of evolutionary pressures as a "natural" ideal. Humans like things that make life easy, but we also don't like change.
I am not opposed to environmentalism and imposing our curated view - but it shouldn't be guilt-ridden. We shouldn't tell lies about what is natural for life by cherrypicking examples of equilibrium and ignoring the trillions of extinct. The equilibrium you see in other species (ants, birds) only exists due the destruction of countless other species. Akin to an alien observing the seemingly stable equilibrium between humans, cockroaches, and pigeons.
Life survived despite incredible climate pressures and invasive species in the past - far more extreme than what is happening now - and reached new levels of complexity thanks to those pressures. There's no reason that will stop.
Having said that, it would be in our long term interest not to continue doing this until the system collapses.
I actually assessed my opponent as someone who has it in for mankind, not an environmentalist (that's your word BTW and doesn't belong in quotes you attribute to me). My point wasn't so much "nature does it to" but rather to illustrate - humans are part of nature and their behavior is not unique. To keep us separate from nature seems to be either human-hating or human-aggrandizing. Given the OPs calling us assholes I figure we can guess which.
From there I was most definitely having more fun than trying to making a point!
You’ve stumbled through the straw men and into the point, my dude. The way of thinking which frames humans as “best animals” is the same one which makes us incapable of averting suicide by ecological collapse.
Consciousness is not just a cool survival trick, it’s a responsibility.
It's as though we were a bunch of single cells arguing about whether we should become a multicellular life form to avoid us all dying. It might in theory be necessary, but it would involve all members giving up autonomy and being willing to act and die on command. That raises two questions - is it really worth it, and is it possible?
I'm not firmly pro or con organizing humanity into a "super organism" to avoid ecological disaster - I'm just saying this is what people are ultimately debating wrt global warming, and it's pretty "out there". I'm not convinced it's feasible, at least not in the near future (next century).
Birds and ants don't reach a "natural equilibrium". They, and all other species, simply (and similarly) exhaust what their habitat will sustain in one way or another, just as humans do.
Almost all the species that ever existed went extinct without the help of humans.
No, not really. These ecosystems adapt to change very, very slowly, and birds and ants very gently come up against the carrying capacity of their surrounding environment, and when they exceed that carrying capacity, their populations cease to grow and may waver, but will reach some equilibrium. They generally do not experience extreme boom and busts, except in extreme cases of invasive species and rapid climate change. They also don't have a tendency to cause mass destruction that takes down the environment around them. The difference with humans is that we use technology and agriculture to continually boost ourselves past the carrying capacity of our local environment, and when that becomes unsustainable--usually wreaking havoc all around us, we move on and spread. Just look throughout history. The pattern repeats over and over.
If birds and ants had the same cycle, they would not have survived hundreds of millions of years like they have.
People just do not understand that our growth rates are so high that they are effectively alien to this planet. So, no, this is not "normal" or "natural" IMO.
Cyanobacteria wiped out most other species on earth: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxygenation_Event
Birds caused mass extinctions and extreme evolutionary pressures: https://news.ucsc.edu/2012/06/giant-insects.html
Trilobites - one of the most diverse, plentiful, and advanced forms of life at the time - went extinct thanks to the evolution of plants.
It is very anthropocentric to view the preservation of the ecological status quo and cessation of evolutionary pressures as a "natural" ideal. Yes, we have a drive to consume and exploit but our desire to preserve what we see as beautiful is no different - it's all just a product of our desires.
I am not opposed to environmentalism - but we shouldn't tell lies about what is natural for life by cherrypicking examples of equilibrium and ignoring the trillions of extinct. The equilibrium you see in other species (ants, birds) only exists due the destruction of countless other species long before humans ever showed up. Just like the stable equilibrium between humans, cockroaches, and pigeons.
It seems to me that while humans are outliers, we're not unique. For instance, we can be compared to the organisms that oxygenated the Earth's atmosphere. Or those that first produced lignin which other organisms couldn't digest for a long time. I recall reading that the latter is why such massive petroleum deposits exist[1]. So our effect on the planet could be considered an echo of that earlier runaway ecological change.
This is closer to what I meant to say, and the term "exhaust" was a poor descriptor. However, the way in which species encounter barriers that define the carrying capacity of an ecosystem are not commonly gentle.
>The difference with humans is that we use technology and agriculture to continually boost ourselves past the carrying capacity of our local environment, and when that becomes unsustainable--usually wreaking havoc all around us, we move on and spread. Just look throughout history. The pattern repeats over and over.
I'm still uncertain at what point in our evolution you draw the line that cuts us out of the animal kingdom.
I see your point, but you seem to be implying that the way you're using "equilibrium", and "natural" is rooted and biology, and this is incorrect. The there is no biological concept of "equilibrium", it's simply a way you could loosely describe a population with low rate of growth for some period.
New species introduced into an ecosystem often wipe out existing species as they grow. It's happened on lots of islands. They eventually reach equilibrium too. It's quite normal and humans aren't special in that regard. We just happen to be the best at it right now.
There is some emotion in your statements. The reason we want to protect the environment is because it has value to humans. It doesn't somehow deserve to be saved independently of us any more than an asteroid deserves to stay floating in space without crashing into any planets. If we can truly and permanently survive OK without as many species, then what's the harm in making them extinct besides emotion?
Adding my own emotional opinion, I think humans really do deserve to dominate everything because we're absolutely the most incredible species ever to live on Earth. Through technology, we've giving ourselves more and more of the abilities of other animals. We can live in environments too hot, cold, or arid for any single other species. We can fly and "swim" across oceans, and even make meat for eating! If evolution had some sort of purpose, it would surely be to create the most capable organisms possible. So far, that's us and every species we wipe out deserved to go because it lost the game of evolution in the same way the poor soccer teams deserve to not win the World Cup.