I just thought of something. With all the privacy issues going on lately, how many of us that are complaining about poor search results have also installed some sort of add on to block Google from tracking us? Can that have something to do with it?
For example, my search results tend (or used to tend) to be skewed towards results dealing with programming or computers in general. If I search for "exception" I generally get results for "Programming Exceptions" rather than any other type of Exception that can exist.