The real missing piece goes back to the same fear the framers had when enacting the Bill of Rights in the first place — namely that by enumerating some rights it would inadvertantly serve to exclude those unenumerated but equally inalienable rights, such as right to self-determination and ownership of one’s own body.
However, this doesn't establish a right to abortion. The justices clearly state that it is not a right by saying it's not covered under the 9th.
It sounds to be threading one hell of a needle as a justification to keep government out of elective abortion. I mean, we have databases which track every narcotic prescription written which law enforcement (including the DEA) can access without a warrant.
That appears to be exactly what it’s doing though!
The registry is not supposed to about who has a prescription, but rather, who has more than their legitimate share of prescriptions. It’s also supposed to be used to identify over-prescribing doctors.
Given that the framers were living in a society where that right was distinctly "alienable", and either were themselves or needed to appease interests that insisted that said right be alienable, I'm not sure they considered that one.
A more charitable, and frankly, reasonable explanation would be that Gorsuch places high priority on limiting government power through to take private property and thinks of many problems through that lens. That's a view he expressed at oral argument in this case[0], in other privacy-related cases [1][2], and in cases in other contexts[3][4].
Virtually all non-unanimous supreme court decisions are ultimately trade-offs between conflicting rights and values. Congress's power to regulate drugs vs a citizen's right to use drugs in religious ceremonies (Smith). The documentary-maker's right to free speech vs the population's right to ensure free and fair elections by limiting corporate spending on elections (Citizens United). A citizen's right not to be searched for incriminating evidence without a warrant vs. a police officer's need to prevent destruction of evidence and ensure their own safety (Robinson).
Different justices place different weight on different rights. Kennedy is a famously protective of free speech, so whenever Free Speech is implicated, he tends to side on the defense of it. Alito places a lot of value in ensuring police have workable rules that can be applied in the field. Those priorities determine where they land on tough issues and how they think issues should be resolved.
I think there's a lot of evidence to suggest Gorsuch cares about protecting property rights and that idea is entirely consistent with his reasoning here (without his harboring a secret anti-Roe agenda).
[0]https://www.oyez.org/cases/2017/16-402 [1] http://www.scotusblog.com/2018/01/argument-analysis-rental-c... [2] https://www.ca10.uscourts.gov/opinions/13/13-7082.pdf [3] https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/17pdf/16-712_87ad.pdf [4] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/201...
There's still a lot of gray area though -- it's easy to say that the money in my bank is my property, even where it is in the care and custody of a third party, so by that argument, Gorsuch's property argument gives me more privacy protections for non-warranted searches to my banking data, but on the other hand, it's not clear that my Google Map data is 'mine', since Google provides it as a service to me for free, and uses that data for other purposes.
I didn't understand him to be quite saying that. I understood him to be saying, "information about oneself is property. The government may not take your property without cause even someone else is holding it for you. Ergo, they cannot take the information here."
As you note--there's a debate that would need to be had whether this is your information that you've given them, or their information that they've created about you and the analogy breaks down a bit for me where that isn't perfectly clear.
Roberts seemed during oral arguments like he might have been trying on the information-is-property argument, "This [data] is not simply created by the company, though. It's a joint venture with the individual carrying the phone. That person helps the company create the record by being there and sending out the pings or whatever." That he writes against it here suggests he either didn't like where it led, or possibly couldn't get a majority to sign on to an approach that would uproot Katz when neither party was asking for it.
Yep, definitately not clear. But that's why it's a good for courts to start thinking about such things so that principles can emerge out of real-world cases.
My guess is that data-ownership is mostly bunk ("information wants to be free"). But privacy advocates who think in those terms are on to something and "ownership" is just the nearest model we can think of. Over time we can evolve a clearer idea of of what that something is.