> is at least in part because of the reliance on package management. If Linux had a stable base set of shared libraries developers could depend on
Except in saying that, you're completely ignoring the fact that X11 by itself requires how many different projects, all of which have different teams, goals, etc.? Just attempting to even get that would wind up in bikesheds at so many levels that it'd be impossible to do. But this has been Linux's problem since the 90s, it's not new at all.
And Linux has always been "just a kernel." Even FreeBSD still has disagreements about what to put in the base system, and they did get along without a true package manager for a while, but not anymore.
> Sure, as long as you only ever want to work within the confines of what is provided by the package manager.
A few weeks ago I needed something the package manager didn't have. So I ported and made another package for it. I also ran into a BeOS app that still used the "appdir" model because nobody updated it, and it still worked.
The package manager isn't "old magic" which must be "appeased" and "worked around." If it doesn't work, or it's missing something, we fix it.
> "Easy" requires the system to try and understand what I want, and we know how well that works for youtube, netflix, and amazon recommendations.
I've reiterated multiple times that you can forego the package manager and use the still-existing "easy" route if you'd like. Why does the package manager's mere existence cause a problem?
> Can you put an application on a USB drive, take it to another Haiku system, and run it from the USB drive without installation? ...
Yes. The executable bit still exists outside of packages, you know ;)
You will need to manually extract said packages, and then set up the `lib` folder properly (just as app developers did for appdirs); and then this relies on the application using relative paths for loading data (which all should, because they can be installed in `~` as well, but I'm not sure we check for conformance on this point just yet.)
You of course loose all the benefits of the package manager -- updates, etc. -- by doing this. But I guess that's what you want.