Unfortunately, it's not really possible to prove/disprove an opinion on what a design element will do.
Additionally, optimization testing allows you to try out different options. Going with someone's (educated) gut feel is a worse decision than exploring the option space.
Ideally, you'd test everything. In the real world, resource constraints apply, so at issue is how to establish an internal discipline where facts trump opinions, and opinions can be tested then either discarded or confirmed.
When it comes to design, there often aren't facts (one may even suggest facts don't exist when it comes to design). Study the history of art to contest that. Otherwise, listen to users like they are humans, and see whether it matches with the designers advice. Simple.