So what if the "certain topic" is something with no immediately obvious thing that "works", e.g. climate change?
This is a special case however, in that we have to assume correctness because otherwise we'll all be much worse off, and the possible cost of reducing pollution are slim in comparison. But if anything I think this supports my point that correctness itself doesn't matter, only the material consequences do.
I assume you're not headed into religious debate territory but I don't imagine pragmatists focus much on metaphysical matters (I know I don't).