Mozilla seems to be confident in that agreement and I have a certain amount of trust in Mozilla which factors into my decision. Yours might be different, so don’t enable that feature or use a different provider.
So your argument is an obvious straw man and one wonders about your motivations to support getting all the browsing meta data into the US by default.
Moving my data from Germany to the US will not make me more secure in any way.
And talking about repressed countries is like "think about the children!" for the rest of us - a nice lever to sell this massive data vacuuming.
That said: I fully expect that at some point Mozilla will want to push adoption of this feature, but not in its most extreme form. I’d expect that a default configuration would use soft fallback.
Which I think is the purpose of almost all experimental feature.
In the blog it is clearly stated that they hope DoH implementations will become standard and common, maybe that even some ISP start offering their own.
Sorry, this got me emotional, but since I started following tech news few years ago the amount of fake news on mozzilla I read is astounding.
And proper fake news. Many, as this article does, do no claim that a new feature dangerous per se, but falsely (I don't think with purpose, that is what I find astounding) quote mozzilla blogs to build an apocalyptic scenario
I'm wondering why the constant and maybe not even ill-intentioned misinformation about the word they say.
I don't want to accuse anyone, I believe that both side value the truth, but it really looks like as if there was a fake news factory against mozzilla
This could include 3rd party reviews, etc.. Who knows?
If NSA/FBI aren't in one's threat profile, one might also be concerned about a court order over something having to do with copyright or patents. Damages for those can be huge. There's both legal and technical firms dedicated to pouring through data for evidence of patent infringements. Many licensing "agreements" start with evidence they find. I don't know much more about this. My wild guess is that they often start with tips from disgruntled workers or maybe those leaving for competitors.
These are main, three threats I'd be concerned about if sharing what I did with a U.S.-based provider. Double true for me given I'm in the jurisdiction of the enforcement agencies.
It also promises not to store your IP associated with the DNS requests https://developers.cloudflare.com/1.1.1.1/commitment-to-priv... so the law enforcement would have to ask Cloudflare to install a wiretap device.
If you're this worried about being traced, it's probably best not to disclose your IP address at all https://blog.cloudflare.com/welcome-hidden-resolver/
Moreover, cloudflare would be in a legal minefield since Mozilla would likely have standing to sue, if cloudflare violates its own terms of service.
So, you basically have to believe the US-based company you trust won't take 8-9 digit bribe, will accept bankruptcy, and/or has people who will do time for your privacy. I don't trust anybody running for-profit companies to do that except for maybe Levison. Even he might change after weighing damage he received vs probably no benefit of principled stand. Maybe he'll stay in the fight, too. Who knows. I do know Cloudfare has financial incentives to take massive investments and/or avoid massive losses. Might work against users at some point.
To be clear, Im a big fan of Cloudfare. They're awesome. There's just upper limit of trust since they're profit-motivated operating in a quasi-police state (ie a Dual State).
Ideally, this would be caught in an audit and ideally Mozilla would be in a position to sue on your behalf.
How many users sue their ISPs over DNS logging, poisoning or other violations of trust.
Terms of service don't overrule federal law or court orders. That's assuming they'll turn down money. RSA told customers they were buying crypto with no mention of backdoors. Yet, they put one in for about $30 million.
So, a company might willingly violate ToS for a pile of cash or unwillingly do it via legal coercion that comes with secrecy order. Leaks indicated most took the bribes. Many more bribes or coercions might have happened since. So, we should just assume its true with companies in surveillance states with other security practices designed with that assumption baked in.
Also, it might not even matter if one isnt doing anything over those connections that's illegal. The backdoor becomes something probable but irrelevant for those users. From there, Cloudfare protdcts them from relevant-to-them threats like DDOS or delays causing lost sales.