What CAN you tell us about the internal data ? Why does the process persist if there's data showing its flawed ?
Perhaps the answer is that there is no systematic interviewing system that actually works well. It seems like trying to create one was the origin of all this pain, and the cargo-culting by companies that don't need a systematic process has amplified it.
Interviewing is an inherently social, inherently subjective process. Such things are highly resistant to systematic approaches.