If I remember correctly, isn't the military surprised that Ender uses the super-bomb against the bugger's planet?
By the way, what's your take on "Cold Equations?"
If I remember correctly, isn't the military surprised that Ender uses the super-bomb against the bugger's planet?
By the way, what's your take on "Cold Equations?"
Stilson, yes. Bonzo, no. Bonzo was effectively dead but still standing when Ender kicked him in the groin.
Are we to assume that he doesn't know that doing such a thing could be lethal?
Ender was 6 when he killed Stilson. I don't think it's unreasonable to believe that a 6 year old, even one of the smartest on the planet, might not have a full appreciation that kicking someone who had just attacked him might kill him or a full appreciation of what death is.
Maybe the scenarios are contrived but I still maintain that Ender is an innocent in both cases because his use of force was intended to prevent serious injury to himself. He was facing superior numbers of physically stronger adversaries.
If I remember correctly, isn't the military surprised that Ender uses the super-bomb against the bugger's planet?
I think they intended for him to use the MDD but none of them wanted to take the moral responsibility for telling him to destroy an entire species. They wanted Xenocide without being responsible for it.
Regarding surprise: Remember that Ender is not just chosen for his intelligence, but also his temperament. Peter and Valentine are just as smart, Peter probably the smartest out of the three. Graff and the others are banking on Ender's survivalist trait to do the hard things when necessary, make the decisions that no one else had the courage to make.
In the final battle, Ender's rationale was this: The yield of the MD device was too low to take the bugger fleet down by itself. The hive knew about the MD device and was countering his actions by constant movements to minimize local clustering. The only option was to target the planet to yield a large enough cascade. Even then, he didn't know if it would be large enough to take out the entire enemy fleet. In the end, it was large enough to destroy half the human fleet as well. He was taking a calculated risk. It was cold, ruthless and utterly unexpected. Even the Hive Queen, who was in touch with his thoughts on and off, didn't think he would do it. When she realizes his true intentions, she tries her best to block his path, throwing ships directly in the line of fire. It was a very high-risk strategy. He could have run out of ships before he got close enough for instance.
The real question is: Would he do it again if placed in the exact same situation with the exact same facts and resources at his disposal? Ender spends the rest of the series struggling with that very question. Ultimately, he comes to realize that, yes, he would do it all over again if he had to.
Thank you for the recommendation on "Cold Equations". Haven't read it, will happily take a look. Hopefully my local library has a copy.
Did you actually read the whole essay? The author makes exactly this point about Ender's mindset. The only thing you seem to be disagreeing on is whether it's a good one.
<spoilers>
The aviation part of me feels the scenario a bit contrived (20% reserve on flights is common). The lack of resistance on the girl's part also strikes me as a bit contrived. She should maybe fight, try to knock the pilot out and jettison him instead. She may go to jail, but that's better than death. Maybe that's what Ender would do...?