I think the focus needs to be on setting a reasonable baseline and encouraging productivity without sacrificing well-being or the work/life balance.
edit: I think maybe I wasn't clear about my last point. I'm very much on the life side of the work/life balance. I'm okay with an employee who puts in 35 hours but is meeting/exceeding expectations. In fact, I encourage it. It's up to the manager and the individual to have an understanding of what's expected.